By Justin Chua (蔡智勋), lawyer and mediator, Chua Tan Associates. Checked November 2026.
Short answer: during a visa application the Department may send two common kinds of letter: a section 56 letter asking for more information or documents, and a section 57 letter, often called a “natural justice letter”, telling you it holds information adverse to you and inviting you to comment within a deadline. A s57 letter is often the last chance before a refusal. The content of the response and the deadline both matter, so have a lawyer review it quickly.
How the two letters differ
- Section 56 (request for information): the Department needs more material to decide, such as updated health checks, police certificates, relationship evidence or employment evidence;
- Section 57 (adverse information): the Department sets out specific information that could lead to refusal, for example inconsistencies with earlier applications, tax or other records, and invites your comment.
Common triggers
- doubts about the authenticity of employment references, qualifications, marriage certificates or bank documents;
- inconsistencies with earlier visa applications, such as marital status, work history or addresses;
- sponsor or employer information that does not match what was declared;
- character issues, such as undeclared charges.
The link with PIC 4020
If the Department considers that an applicant gave a bogus document or false or misleading information, it may refuse under public interest criterion 4020 (PIC 4020), which can also prevent the grant of some visas for several years. Identity concerns carry more serious consequences. A s57 response therefore needs both an explanation and an assessment of whether there is a reasonable basis and evidence for it.
How to respond
- confirm the deadline immediately, as it is usually short; if genuinely needed, ask in writing for an extension before it expires, though one is not guaranteed;
- respond point by point to each item, rather than a general denial;
- attach documents supporting the explanation, with translations of Chinese documents;
- make sure the response is consistent with earlier applications and evidence, so as not to create new inconsistencies;
- do not lodge new documents without verifying them, especially documents obtained through an agent.
How we help
Our immigration work is handled by two Accredited Specialists in Immigration Law. We read Chinese documents directly, review the Department’s letter, earlier applications and evidence, and prepare the written response; if a refusal follows, we can act in Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) review and judicial review. See Australian immigration lawyers and partner visa refusals.
Frequently asked questions
Does a s57 letter mean the visa will be refused?
Not necessarily. The letter gives you a chance to respond. A good response may be accepted; no response or a poor one greatly increases the risk of refusal.
An agent lodged my earlier application and I don’t recognise what the letter says. What now?
Get a full copy of the earlier applications quickly, and if needed the Department’s records through a freedom of information (FOI) request, before deciding how to respond.
The deadline is close. Is there still time?
Contact us immediately. Depending on the situation, a preliminary response or an extension request can be lodged before the deadline.
Clients anywhere in Australia or overseas: meet us at our Melbourne office or by video, in English, Mandarin or Cantonese. Book a paid 30-minute consultation, or call (03) 9602 3988, WhatsApp +61 490 369 102 or WeChat chuatan262. If you go ahead with us, the fee is credited to your first invoice. City pages: Chinese-speaking lawyers by city.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. You must not rely on it for any particular matter. Laws and procedures differ between states, and every case depends on its facts; please book a consultation for advice on your situation.
Chua Tan Associates services: Australian lawyers | divorce lawyer | family lawyer | wills lawyer | conveyancing lawyer | immigration lawyer Perth | immigration lawyer Darwin | migration lawyer Hobart
Reviewed by the firm's Accredited Specialists in Immigration Law.
Chua Tan Associates has practised in Melbourne since 1990.
Other cities: Chinese-speaking lawyers in every Australian city