Most families never need a lawyer to deal with their child’s school. But when a child is suspended or expelled, refused a place, left without the support they need, or caught between separated parents, the stakes can rise quickly. Decisions made in these moments can follow a child for years, and many of the processes have short, strict time limits.
This article outlines the most common legal issues Victorian parents face with schools, and the options available when something goes wrong.
Government and non-government schools follow different rules.
The first question is always: what kind of school is it?
- Victorian government schools They are bound by legislation, Ministerial Orders, and Department of Education policies. These set out formal processes for discipline, enrollment, and complaints, including rights of appeal.
- Catholic and independent schools are governed mainly by the enrolment contract you signed and the school’s own policies, together with registration standards, anti-discrimination law and the general law (such as negligence).
The right strategy depends heavily on which framework applies, so it is worth confirming this before taking any step.
1. Suspension and expulsion
In Victorian government schools, suspensions and expulsions are governed by Ministerial Order 1125 – Procedures for Suspension and Expulsion of Students in Government Schools. The Order sets the grounds on which a principal may act and the process they must follow.
Key points for parents:
- Suspension and expulsion are meant to be measures of last resort. The Department’s own guidance describes suspension as a serious disciplinary measure best kept for situations where other approaches have not worked.
- Your child is entitled to a support person. The Order requires a “relevant person” to participate in the process, support the student, and advocate for them. This is usually a parent or carer.
- Both separated parents should be told. Department guidance states that where parents are separated, all parents and carers must be notified of an intention to suspend or expel.
- Students with disabilities have extra protection. Decisions must be consistent with the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities and anti-discrimination laws, not just the Order.
- Expulsions can be appealed, but the time limit is short. An appeal is lodged with the Department using the Expulsion Appeal Form, generally within 10 business days of receiving the Notice of Expulsion. Grounds include that the principal did not follow the required process.
In non-government schools, the process is set by the school’s own policies and the enrolment contract. Even so, schools are generally expected to act fairly, and a decision made without proper process or for a discriminatory reason may be open to challenge.
Watch out for “informal expulsions”. Sometimes a family is encouraged to withdraw their child “voluntarily”, or is told the child would be “better off elsewhere”, without any formal decision being made. Accepting this can mean losing the appeal rights that a formal expulsion would carry. If you are being steered towards withdrawal, get advice before you agree.
2. Enrollment and school zone disputes
Every eligible child has a right to enrol in a Victorian government school, and a child who lives within a school’s zone must be offered a place there. Problems usually arise when families seek a place at a school outside their zone, or when there is a dispute about the family’s permanent address.
If a school refuses a place, you can lodge a written appeal with the school. If that appeal fails, you can escalate it to the Department’s Regional Director, whose decision concludes the process. Regional appeals have fixed closing dates tied to the statewide Foundation and Year 7 placement timelines, so it is important to act promptly.
3. Children with disabilities and learning needs
Under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth), the Disability Standards for Education 2005 and Victoria’s Equal Opportunity Act 2010, schools, both government and non-government, must make reasonable adjustments so that students with disability can take part in education on the same basis as other students.
Common disputes include:
- Adjustments agreed at Student Support Group meetings not being put into place;
- a child being excluded from classes, excursions or activities because of disability-related behaviour;
- pressure to reduce a child’s attendance to part-time hours; and
- disagreements over funding, aides or assessment arrangements.
Where these cannot be resolved with the school, complaints can be made to the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission or the Australian Human Rights Commission, and in some cases taken to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). Careful records, including reports, emails and meeting notes, make a significant difference to how these matters unfold.
4. Bullying, safety and injury
Schools owe students a duty of care. Where a school knew, or should have known, about a risk to a child, such as ongoing bullying or unsafe activity, and failed to take reasonable steps, the school may be liable for resulting harm.
Parents should report concerns in writing, keep copies of all correspondence, and record dates, incidents and any medical or psychological treatment. If your child has been injured, time limits for compensation claims apply, so early advice is important.
5. Separated parents and school decisions
Schools frequently find themselves in the middle of family disputes. The Department’s policy expects separated parents with shared decision-making responsibility to consult each other. It also makes clear that schools are not the place to resolve disputes between parents.
Common issues we see include:
- one parent enrolling a child in a new school without the other’s agreement;
- a parent being denied school reports or information;
- pick-up and access arrangements where there are parenting orders or intervention orders; and
- disagreements over private versus government schooling, or who pays the fees.
Schools rely on the court orders and documents parents provide, so it is important that the school holds up-to-date copies of any orders. Disputes about where a child goes to school are a parenting issue under family law, and are often best resolved through family dispute resolution or mediation before they reach court.
6. Fees, contracts and private school disputes
Enrollment in an independent or Catholic school is a contract. Disputes can arise over unpaid fees, forfeited deposits, a term’s notice of withdrawal, or a school cancelling an enrollment. The terms of the enrolment contract and the school’s published policies are central, and some terms may be open to challenge under Australian Consumer Law.
7. International students
For international students, a school’s decision can have consequences beyond education. Discipline issues, attendance problems, or a change of school may affect a student’s visa conditions. These matters need to be handled with both the school process and the immigration position in mind.
How complaints escalate in government schools
For most issues in government schools, the path is:
- The school: raise the concern with the teacher, then the principal, ideally in writing.
- The Department’s regional office: if the school cannot resolve it, or the complaint concerns the principal.
- The Independent Office for School Dispute Resolution (IOSDR): a free, independent body that uses mediation and other alternative dispute resolution methods to help resolve complex, escalated disputes between families and government schools. Referrals usually come through the Department, and both the school and the family need to agree to take part.
Some decisions, such as expulsions and enrolment refusals, have their own separate appeal processes, and the general complaints process does not replace them.
Practical tips for parents
- Put it in writing. Follow up phone calls and meetings with an email summarising what was discussed.
- Ask for the policy. Request a copy of the school policy or procedure the school is relying on.
- Bring a support person. You are generally entitled to have someone with you at formal meetings.
- Watch the deadlines. Appeals can be resolved in as little as a few days.
- Keep your child’s education on track. Whatever the dispute, make sure arrangements are in place so your child does not fall behind.
- Get advice early. It is far easier to shape a process from the start than to unwind a decision after it has been made.
How Chua Tan Associates can help
We assist families with school and education disputes, including appeals regarding suspension and expulsion, enrollment appeals, complaints of disability discrimination, disputes with independent schools, and education issues arising from separation. As accredited mediators and family dispute resolution practitioners, we also help families and schools reach practical solutions without the cost and stress of litigation.
We regularly assist Chinese-speaking families and can advise in English, Mandarin and Cantonese.
If you are facing a dispute with your child’s school, book an initial consultation With us. We will review your situation, identify the applicable processes and deadlines, and outline your options.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Policies and procedures change from time to time, and the right approach depends on your circumstances. Please contact us for advice about your situation.
Talk to a lawyer about your situation
Book a paid 30-minute consultation in English, Mandarin or Cantonese, in person in Melbourne or by video from anywhere. If you go ahead with us, the fee is credited to your first invoice.
Book a consultation
Written by the Chua Tan Associates legal team | Reviewed by
Justin Chua, lawyer and nationally accredited mediator
Last updated: 4 November 2026