Mr Chen has three children. His youngest son cut off contact with the family twenty years ago, and Mr Chen wants to leave his Melbourne home only to the two children who have looked after him for years. He asks: 'It's my will. Can I leave my youngest son nothing at all?'
The direct answer: you can write your will that way, and it will not be invalid because of it. But in Victoria, a child who is left out can make a family provision claim under Part IV of the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic), asking the court to order proper maintenance and support from the estate. Whether the court agrees depends on the circumstances.
At a glance
- Children, including stepchildren, are among the 'eligible persons' who can make a claim.
- The court's central questions are whether the deceased had a moral duty to provide for the applicant and whether the will made adequate provision.
- A claim generally must be made within six months after the grant of probate or letters of administration.
- Recording your reasons and keeping evidence is more useful than simply writing 'nothing' in the will.
- Victoria currently has no 'notional estate' regime like New South Wales, but that does not mean assets can be freely moved out of the estate.
First, let's understand the basic rules of claiming.
For information about which children can file claims, how the court determines “moral responsibility,” and the six-month deadline, please see here. In Victoria, who can challenge a will? What is the deadline? This article focuses on the arrangements that can be made when making a will.
Common arrangement methods
- Given and left behind records before death If a child has already received funds for a home purchase or large amounts of support, the transfer records should be preserved and mentioned in the will or declaration, and the court will consider these former benefits.
- Replacing direct provision with lifetime benefits or the right to reside Allowing a family member to use the property during their lifetime or receive the proceeds and then leave the rest to other children.
- Establishing a testamentary trust The trustee pays the living or educational expenses for a specific child as needed, rather than providing a large lump sum at one time. This is suitable for situations where parents are concerned about their children's financial ability or the risk of marriage.
- Balanced distribution of life insurance premiums For example, leave the family business to the children involved in the management, and then use insurance payouts to take care of the other children.
- Communicate in advance In family meetings or situations where a neutral mediator is present, explaining arrangements often reduces disputes more than letting the children know about them when the will is read out.
Each arrangement has its pros and cons; it should also be considered in conjunction with retirement plan nominations and the overall ownership structure of the property.
Reducing the risk when making your will
- Record your reasons: attach a separate signed and dated statement that objectively records why you are leaving little or nothing, avoiding emotional or inaccurate accusations.
- Keep evidence: for example, records of money given to the child for a home, school fees or loans.
- Consider a modest gift: sometimes leaving a reasonable amount reduces the incentive to litigate more than leaving nothing.
- Plan assets as a whole: jointly owned property, superannuation and life insurance usually pass outside the will, but planning must stay lawful and consider the effect on other family members.
- Confirm capacity: older will-makers or those with health issues may consider having a doctor assess their capacity and keep a record.
- Review regularly: check the will again after family changes such as reconciliation, remarriage or the birth of grandchildren.
What should cross-border families watch for?
Many Chinese families have children spread across China, Hong Kong, Malaysia or Singapore. As long as the estate includes property in Victoria (especially real estate), a child overseas may also bring a claim in Victoria. In addition, places have different rules about children's mandatory shares, and a separate will made overseas may face local forced heirship or reserved-share rules, so each jurisdiction needs to be considered.
Frequently asked questions
If I write 'I deliberately leave nothing to X' in my will, will that stop a claim?
It will not stop it entirely. It shows the omission was not an oversight, but the court will still examine whether a moral duty existed. Clear, objective reasons and evidence are more helpful.
Can an adult child who is financially independent still claim?
They can apply, but the court will look closely at their financial position and needs. An adult child in a strong financial position generally has a lower chance of receiving additional provision.
Can a child living in China claim in Victoria?
Yes. Where the applicant lives does not affect eligibility; what matters is whether they are an eligible person and whether the estate falls within the Victorian court's jurisdiction.
Is it safe to put the house into joint names with one child?
Property held as joint tenants usually passes directly to the surviving owner and is not part of the estate. But this immediately affects ownership, stamp duty and other taxes, and may cause other disputes, so get professional advice first.
Is there any chance if the six-month deadline is missed?
You can ask the court for an extension, but the court will consider the reasons for delay, the effect on beneficiaries and whether the estate has already been distributed. The earlier you get advice, the better.
Chua Tan Associates has practised in Melbourne since 1990, providing wills, powers of attorney, probate and estate administration services in Mandarin, Cantonese and English. Justin Chua is a STEP Affiliate and a nationally accredited mediator, and the firm has a notary public who can notarise documents for use overseas. For help, call 03 9602 3988 or contact us online. We can meet at our Melbourne CBD office or by video.
This page provides general information only and is not legal advice.
Talk to a lawyer about your situation
Book a 30-minute paid consultation in English, Mandarin or Cantonese, in person in Melbourne or by video from anywhere in the world. If you go ahead and instruct us, the consultation fee is credited to your first invoice.
Book a consultation
This article is part of the guide: Wills and Estates - See all related guides
重要提示: 本文仅为一般资讯, 不得作为依据. 本文并非法律, 税务或财务意见, 没有考虑您的个人情况, 亦可能未反映发布后的法律变化. 其他国家的法律也可能适用. 请勿仅依据本文采取或不采取任何行动. 阅读本文或与我们联系, 并不构成律师与客户关系. 如需针对您情况的意见, 请预约咨询.
Written by the Chua Tan Associates legal team | Reviewed by
Justin Chua, lawyer and nationally accredited mediator
Last updated: 4 November 2026
Written by Justin Chua, lawyer and mediator at Chua Tan Associates, nationally accredited mediator (NMAS), registered Family Dispute Resolution Practitioner and STEP member.
Chua Tan Associates has practised in Melbourne since 1990.